Strength of Schedule or Wins?

One of great things about the NCAA tournament is determining the bubble teams and who's in and who's out.  Very often this is done with a blind test of Team X vs Team Y.  You're given each team's resume but without the team name.  So I figured this could be applied to section seeding at the high school level.  So here are 2 teams from the same section with the names removed.

Team A
Overall Record: 8-4
The 8 victories are over opponents with a 34.2% winning percentage. 
Average margin of victory: 17.6 pts
3 losses are to opponents with a 84.4% winning percentage.
Average margin of defeat: 13.3 pts
Opponents games vs Team A are removed in those percentages.
8 of the 12 games are against opponents who are 1 class below them (5-3)
No games against opponents in a higher class
Team A is 1-1 in section games

Team B
Overall Record: 4-8
3 wins are over opponents with a 55.2% winning percentage.
Average margin of victory: 12.7 pts
The 8 losses are to opponents with a 62.5% winning percentage.
Average margin of defeat 11.9 pts.
Opponents games vs Team B are removed in those percentages.
Team B is 0-3 against opponents from 1 class above.  1-0 against opponents from 1 class below.
Team B is 2-3 in section games

Other facts
Team B defeated Team A by 16 points in the 1 head-head meeting.  Team B hosted that game.

They also have played 1 common opponent.  Both teams hosted this common opponent who we'll call Team C.
Team A lost to Team C by 29 points
Team B lost to Team C by 6 points in overtime.

Team A has the higher QRF but Team B is very close.

If the seeding meeting was today, who do you give the higher seed?

No comments:

Post a Comment

Have a different take than mine? You can provide your take here.